Virtual or remote board meetings were originally conceived as a quick way to assemble during times of crisis to communicate and solve problems. Software has greatly facilitated this capability among remote teams, and COVID-19 brought the need for flexibility and online centralization into sharp relief. Shifting to an online meeting format for board, committee and executive meetings – or any other meeting of a sensitive nature – has enabled leaders to continue important conversations while maintaining social distancing protocols. Remote work isn’t new. Research from 2019 shows it was already on the upswing, and the pandemic has heightened awareness of this work model. Even companies like Facebook and Google have extended their work-from-home option through 2021. Others, such as Twitter and Microsoft, are moving to an indefinite work-from-home model.
What Is a Virtual or Remote Board Meeting?Remote board meetings offer a way to convene your board without requiring in-person attendance. These virtual, digital meetings make use of the internet and videoconferencing software to allow real-time discussion and foster a sense of personal face-to-face communication even when your board can’t sit around the same physical table.
Benefits: Why Go Remote?While one of the main reasons for holding remote board meetings is to adapt to the necessity for meeting remotely during times of crisis, going virtual brings other practical and measurable benefits as well.
Reduce ExpensesHosting an in-person meeting requires space, which costs money. By holding remote meetings, you can save money on meeting space, flights and hotel rooms for out-of-town attendees, and any other expenses involved with hosting an in-person meeting. On average, companies report saving $30 billion a day by permitting their employees to work from home due to savings on infrastructure, utilities, and more. Dell saves $12 million a year by letting 25% of employees work from home. These numbers add up because each remote employee saves a company $11,000 per year. As far as meetings go, you can get an estimate by using Harvard’s tool to calculate how much you’ll save by going virtual.
Save TimeYou’ll save more than just money. Board members are likely juggling other responsibilities that prevent them from attending in person as often as they'd like. Virtual board meetings enable easier scheduling because they reduce travel time and overall time commitment of a board meeting. It also resolves the need for syncing up calendars to make sure the space is available. According to Harvard Business Review, videoconferencing can save half the time of in-person, phone, or email meetings and leads to higher levels of collaborations on decisions. A reduction in the time it takes to meet, alongside increased schedule flexibility, will also likely be appealing to those considering joining the board, and your future board recruitment efforts may benefit.
Increase AttendanceEliminating travel and its associated time commitment removes a major barrier to attendance participation. Those who want to attend will have a greater opportunity to do so, which will, in turn, increase turnout. Board members who were missing meetings due to time constraints may be able to attend again.
Improve DiversityDepending on your needs, in-person board meetings may have limited your ability to have full representation on your board. With geographic restrictions lifted, your board members can be based anywhere, even across the globe. You can also better accommodate individuals with hearing difficulty through assistive technology. It also opens up new ways to support people who would otherwise find it difficult to serve due to a disability or illness. Diversity helps encourage various perspectives, strengthening your board.
Enhance GovernanceBoard management software and tools will simplify planning virtual board meetings. You'll have an increased opportunity to focus on important governance issues that often get overlooked. If you use a platform to manage meetings, you'll also benefit from a secure online environment that allows you to both host meetings and communicate in between them, too.
Maintain Social DistancingWhile the above benefits of remote meetings will always be relevant, one of the most significant benefits virtual meetings offer during 2020 and 2021 is the ability to maintain social distancing. With the COVID-19 pandemic still in play, an in-person meeting isn't an option for some people. Being able to meet remotely solves the problem of how you'll continue to meet during a lockdown or any other situation that requires social distancing measures.
Challenges: Things to Watch ForMeetings held remotely face a common set of struggles, such as technical difficulties, trouble engaging participants and a lack of efficiency. Remote meetings can be equally as effective if you know and address the challenges you'll face. These challenges aren’t insignificant. Yet, they are easily overcome with a little effort and should not factor heavily into your decision to take advantage of meeting virtually.
1) LegalityEvery type of business has different protocols, whether those rules are dictated by the jurisdiction of the company or the organization's own bylaws. Some of those regulations require meeting participants to be present in person to vote on issues or to execute other meeting business. Remote meetings can often help facilitate these actions. For instance, when an in-person vote is required, it may be possible to hold the discussion portion of a meeting remotely and hold only the vote in person, in as socially distanced a manner as possible. That way, in-person actions don’t need to be postponed until it’s fully safe to meet in person again. Similarly, many organizations have the ability to amend their own bylaws to allow for voting and other actions via virtual meetings.
2) SecurityYour information needs to be protected, and when using technology, it’s crucial to keep security in mind. Choosing the right platform to hold your board meeting can make a big difference in facing this challenge. Hackers are a concern, especially when using personal WiFi networks. Zoom experienced this firsthand during the rush in membership during the height of the pandemic. Phishing emails are another issue as are malicious attachments. This is part of why you should use a secure teleconferencing platform to send information regarding meetings or any documents related to them. Privacy could also be a limited due to bystanders in a public space or within the home. Another consideration includes thin walls of a hotel room or house, which could result in private information being leaked.
3) EngagementWhen you aren't meeting in person, it can be hard to read body language or detect other nonverbal cues, such as facial expressions. Without the ability to see people or look them in the eye directly, it can be harder to engage participants. Both of these issues can create misunderstandings and will need to be a factor in deciding who and how many will be on camera at a time. Additionally, it can be tempting for participants to do other things while on a remote meeting call, which can cause distractions among participants, further reducing engagement.
4) TechnologyWhile many people understand the nuances of technology these days, not everyone does. Board members who do not feel as comfortable with technology may need a little more support. Also, if someone's internet goes down, they will not be able to attend the meeting, or the meeting will need to be paused.
Tips: How to Run Your Remote MeetingsThere are many things you can do to help your virtual meetings run more smoothly. If you are new to meeting remotely, there are ways to smooth the adjustment period. Experienced or not, the suggestions below may be good to keep in mind.
What to Do Before the MeetingWhen prepping for your meetings, you’ll need to take steps to ensure the meeting will run smoothly. It’s best to prepare in advance by completing the following steps before your meeting begins:
- Choose the right platform
- Test and anticipate
- Have a backup plan
- Choose the best time
- Assign tasks
- Deliver the agenda
- Ensure access and security
Choose the Right PlatformPicking the platform to host your meetings is the first step to ensuring a successful remote board meeting. The best platforms are secure, accessible, easy-to-use and packed with tools to help your business.
Test and AnticipateNothing is worse than hosting a meeting only to have the technology fail. It's important to test your WiFi connection, your video and audio equipment, and your setup before beginning. Encourage all participants to do the same. Also, if you are the host, do a trial run of the software to ensure you are familiar with using it.
Have a Backup PlanIf your technology fails or something comes up, be sure to have a backup plan, and make sure all your board members know what it is. This might include arranging a different time to meet, shortening the meeting and carrying out the rest of it via email, or having someone step in to fill the person's shoes that can't attend.
Choose the Best TimeBe aware of time zones and schedules to ensure the majority of your members can attend. You can also consider breaking up longer meetings into smaller chunks, such as one hour a day for three days. Taking breaks during the meeting can also be helpful.
Assign TasksMeetings go more smoothly when everyone understands the distribution of responsibilities. One way to keep the meeting on track is to assign tasks or roles. Choose a meeting secretary to keep the minutes, or appoint a time tracker to keep the meeting on schedule. Be clear about the task expectations as well, so that everyone knows what their specific job requires of them.
Deliver the AgendaA clear, specific agenda will keep your meeting focused and on topic at all times. Involve board members in the agenda-setting process, asking what topics need to be covered. Then, send copies of the agenda and any relevant documents to attendees as far in advance as possible, so they have time to review information, add any points and prepare for the meeting. This should be done via a secure board portal rather than through emails.
Ensure Access and SecurityBefore the meeting, make sure that each participant has access to whichever platform you are using and that they understand your security expectations. It might help to have a guest login available for last-minute attendees to use, if your platform requires attendees to be members. Along with the agenda, send attendees any files or documents they need to review before the meeting so that everyone is on the same page, but be sure to send it using the secure platform to avoid cybersecurity issues. One way to encourage this is to have your members use hard-to-decipher passwords for their logins, for example, or use a secured WiFi network with a VPN.
What to Do During the MeetingIf you’re the host, you’ll want to make sure the meeting runs successfully. Take these steps at the beginning of the meeting, and revisit them throughout to ensure participants' adherence:
- Get there first
- Introduce everyone
- Review etiquette
- Go over best practices
- Encourage interaction
- Establish next steps
- Ask for feedback
Get There FirstAs the host of the meeting, you'll want to arrive at least five minutes early so you can greet participants as they join. You'll also be able to tackle any last-minute issues that come up before starting.
Introduce EveryoneIn the beginning, it's important to take time to introduce everyone, including yourself. You can make introductions or boost participation by inviting others to speak. If anyone joins late, pause to introduce them, but don't go through the other introductions again, which will extend the meeting unnecessarily.
Review EtiquetteBe sure to remind everyone of meeting etiquette. They should disable computer notifications, pop-ups and sounds so they don't cause an issue. Cell phone ringers should be turned off as well. Remind participants to be aware of their surroundings and where they've chosen to log in from to maintain everyone's privacy.
Go Over Best PracticesTo set the stage for an effective virtual meeting, it helps to take a few minutes at the beginning after introductions to cover best practices. Discuss whether you will mute participants, how they can unmute themselves, what the behavior expectations are for actively participating and avoiding distractions, and how participants should interject comments or raise questions in the conversation.
Encourage InteractionInteraction during a remote meeting can be difficult, so encouraging it among your participants is important. Make sure everyone speaks at the beginning of the meeting, whether to introduce themselves or share an achievement. This is also a great way to take attendance. Continue to encourage interaction throughout the meeting by letting your participants ask questions or make comments. This way, they don't forget anything important or feel left out.
Check In RegularlyBecause some may find it difficult to share their thoughts on a remote call, checking in with attendees after every agenda point can help ensure their voices are heard. Check-ins also allow you to interject if the conversation is getting off track or running over the time allotted.
Establish Next StepsAt the end of the meeting, before you ask for feedback, be sure to cover the next steps you plan to carry out after the meeting so that everyone has shared expectations. At the end of the meeting, everyone should know what they are supposed to do, so assign responsibilities right away. Clearly defined tasks and deadlines are best. If you don’t do this before the end of the call, remember to assign them in a post-meeting follow-up communication.
Ask for FeedbackAt the end of the meeting, ask for feedback. This enhances board engagement and lets people know their opinions hold value. Let them know they don’t have to give all their feedback on the spot because you'll send a follow-up later, but you're open to hearing real-time feedback as well.
What to Do After the MeetingAlthough the meeting is over, your job is not done. Take these steps to make sure your meeting was a success, improve the efficiency of future meetings and increase engagement:
- Send minutes
- Ask for feedback
- Review minutes and feedback and note changes
- Begin the next steps
1) Send MinutesAfter the meeting is over, whoever recorded the minutes should send them to you for review, and then you should send them out to all attendees. This will keep everyone on task for after-meeting items and help with follow-through. Good minutes provide key details, use an objective voice and provide a review of the meeting's agenda. It’s helpful if notetakers follow the same template for each meeting. When you're ready to send the minutes, be sure to do so securely and include any other follow-up information you need to provide.
2) Ask for FeedbackWhen you ask for feedback at the end of the meeting, not everyone will likely be comfortable offering it at that moment. Also, people will remember other things after the fact. Sending out a link that allows them to fill out a survey or provide feedback anonymously will help generate more informative feedback that can direct future meetings.
3) Review Minutes, Feedback and Note ChangesAs the host of the meeting, make sure to review the minutes and all feedback and to create a list of possible improvements or changes, along with what went well. That way, you can begin improving upon your meeting efficiency and participant engagement. Taking this time is a crucial follow-up step after you’ve kept minutes and asked for feedback. If you don’t review and consider them, those efforts will be useless.
4) Begin the Next StepsNo meeting is complete until you’ve begun to take the next steps. Whether you create new projects or tasks or follow up with specific people to guide them in the process, take action to ensure that at the next meeting, you’ll have progress and resolutions to report.
Other Points to ConsiderWhen you aren't getting together in person, cultivating a sense of camaraderie can be challenging. Building trust is important within a board, so finding time to engage in personal, trust-building activities is helpful. If your situation allows, it’s ideal to gather the whole team in person at least once a year. Also consider scheduling a virtual social meeting between board meetings. Virtual breakout rooms offer another way to become more intimate with each other, allowing you to partner up participants for small-group interactions and deeper engagement. Remote board meetings need breaks just like regular meetings, so be sure to build those in. Keep the excitement alive by having guest attendees, such as industry experts. Plan breakout sessions with learning time. You can widen the circle of attendance for these special remote meetings beyond just the board to include other employees or members to further facilitate interaction and growth.
Tools: Making Remote Board Meetings Even BetterIt is imperative to ensure your company uses the right technology and processes to effectively and legally run your remote meetings. Now that you know the ins and outs of what makes virtual meetings so powerful, you need the right software to ensure you can conduct a quality meeting online just as you would in person. And with the right software, you can reduce concerns about sharing sensitive information online. Diligent has all the tools you need. With Diligent, the process is even easier, providing peace of mind that meeting materials are confidential and secure within the platform. Diligent's board portal system has industry-leading security built right in. Logging into the portal is easy, and you can access everything in one place. As things get shared, changed or added, every meeting participant is updated in real time. It's easy to set up and invite participants to your meeting. Simply share a video link to your members; participants will click the link and be taken to the secure portal for the meeting. Everything happens within the secure portal, and everything remains there when you're done, allowing you to trace back for reference or follow-up. The tools are backed by award-winning customer support available 24/7/365, and included training helps your business make the most of the software. All of our tools work together holistically to ensure that your board meetings function smoothly and securely. There’s nothing to download, and you don’t need to worry whether the technology will work. Here's how Diligent makes your meetings easier.
Is Virtual the Future of Board Meetings?So the real question is, are virtual meetings better? If so, they may stick around long after the pandemic. Having a fully contained platform reduces your board's reliance on non-secure texts and emails, ensures that confidential information is securely distributed, prevents confusion and allows everyone involved to remain focused on the tasks at hand. With this peace of mind, you can continue to address important board matters without interruption, no matter what life throws your way.
The Rising Tide of ESG – Navigating the Road Ahead
The Board's Role in Leading and Enabling GRC
Board and Executive Collaboration: Components of a Secure Platform for the Evolving Workplace